As much as I enjoyed RDR2, I would have rather it been a sequel instead of a prequel because I admittedly wasn't all that interested in playing out the past events of John's gang. I also think that it would have allowed for more creative freedom since they wouldn't have been stuck trying to make everything tie into RDR so much. And to be honest, I've never really been a fan of prequels in any medium because it usually feels like they're making it up as they go along since they're trying to make up a past for an already established future. There's exceptions of course, I thought that Life is Strange: Before the Storm and Yakuza 0 we're good prequels for example. However, I usually prefer experiencing earlier events before later events instead of experiencing them after.
Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays
